Frustulia vulgaris - Self-organization, Cooperation, and Division of Labor

Start and end of the expansion work at one end of the tube

Previous articles have described the division of labour and cooperation in F. vulgaris. While this is evident, the underlying mechanisms are not. As with social insects, it is not reasonable to assume the existence of a central intelligence. Self-organisation mechanisms seem the most likely explanation. No evidence of central control within the colony was found.

First, let's explain the question in more detail.

  • The cooperation among the diatoms in Section I consists of their jointly applying pressure to the end, thereby stretching the tube, moving it forward, and depositing EPS. In Section II, it consists of frequent movement (in both directions) strengthening the walls.
  • Processes are necessary at the start and end of the activity because expansion of the colony at one end is time-limited. This process usually builds up slowly over a period of a few hours and then disappears. During formation, diatoms increasingly concentrate in the area near one end, gradually becoming denser with frequent sharp density fluctuations, and eventually extending the tube. This process can take several hours. The end of the extension is marked by the migration of diatoms into Section III — that is, the freely available space. One could also say that the area around the tip now belongs to Section III as well.
  • There must be an organizational mechanism that ensures the participating diatoms exhibit the required behavior—that is, that they react appropriately when encountering obstacles and when spontaneously changing direction. The same applies to Section II. Here, the diatoms must be kept in the required section, thereby ensuring asymmetric behavior with regard to spontaneous changes in direction of movement.


Observations on individual diatoms

Only a few of our observations provide concrete information about the mechanisms of self-organization. Occasionally, a diatom is pushed through the jelly layer at the tip of the tube. The opening usually closes again quickly, so that only a single diatom escapes.

One then observes that this diatom, which is now moving across the substrate, appears to search for the tube and always remains in its immediate vicinity. It does not appear to be possible to enter the tube. The following video shows this process, from escaping from the tip to moving along the tube. The video in the “Colony Expansion” section also shows such a diatom outside the colony, approaching the tube again.

A colony from which a diatom in Section I is released into the surrounding environment. It seeks out the vicinity of the tube (360x time-lapse).

One possible explanation could be the existence of an attractant (chemotaxis) that is released, at least in the area where the organism moves forward, and passes through the tube into the surrounding space.


Hypothesis on Self-Organization, Cooperation, and the Division of Labor

As an aggregation process involving the local structure only makes sense near one end, it seems reasonable to assume that the organization begins when a diatom encounters an end. In most cases, such a diatom turns around without visibly influencing other diatoms. For reasons that are not apparent, it may remain in the vicinity of the tip, although the usual spontaneous reversal of direction is not restricted. The hypothesis is that it alters its own behavior and releases a signaling molecule that, on the one hand, causes other diatoms to adapt their behavior and, in turn, release this same molecule. (Analogous to quorum sensing, as seen in bacteria.)

Since a key piece of information is the direction in which the tip is located, the gradient of the signaling substance could enable directional detection. To ensure that a division occurs between Section I and Section II and that the number of diatoms in Section I remains limited, measuring concentration could serve as a controlling criterion (gradient sensing). A concentration above a certain threshold value could counteract further aggregation.
This explanatory model fulfills essential requirements, but it is incomplete because it cannot provide criteria for when an organizational structure dissolves. Energy consumption or a time-based control mechanism seem plausible. The hypothesis is minimalistic in the sense that it is limited to a single signaling molecule. Additional molecules could facilitate cell differentiation and the demarcation of regions.


Publication
This research on Frustulia vulgaris is described in detail in a paper submitted for this book under the title “Observation of cooperation and division of labor in colony formation of the tube-dwelling diatom Frustulia vulgaris in culture”:

Colonial Diatoms [DCHN, Volume in the series: Diatoms: Biology & Applications, series editor: Janice L. Pappas, in preparation]” by Mary Ann Tiffany (Editor), Ille C. Gebeshuber (Editor), Florian Zischka (2026).

Non-peer-reviewed preprint (May 2026):

​